Rental Market Trends in Shirley, NY

The average rent in Shirley, NY is around $1250 per month. However, this can vary depending on the neighborhood, the size of the rental unit, and the property's condition. For example, rents are typically higher in desirable areas close to amenities and popular destinations. Larger apartments or homes with multiple bedrooms or modern amenities can also be more expensive. Keep these factors in mind when searching for a rental in Shirley, NY.

Currently, there are 4 rental properties available in Shirley, NY. This includes a variety of options such as apartments, condos, town homes, single-family homes, single rooms, shared rooms and pg accommodations catering to different budgets and preferences. So, if you're looking for a place to rent in Shirley, NY, you have plenty of choices to explore!

If you're looking for budget-friendly neighborhoods in Shirley, NY, consider these options:

• Broad Channel: Average rent is $1450 per month.
• Bergen Beach: Average rent is $1425 per month.
• Canarsie: Average rent is $1425 per month.
• Blissville: Average rent is $1180 per month.
• Hamilton Heights: Average rent is $1129 per month.
• Lindenwood: Average rent is $1081 per month.

The most expensive neighborhoods in Shirley, NY are:

• Heartland Village: Average rent is $875 per month.
• Grymes Hill: Average rent is $751 per month.
• Douglaston: Average rent is $763 per month.
• Soundview: Average rent is $684 per month.
• New Dorp Beach: Average rent is $664 per month.
• Dongan Hills: Average rent is $816 per month.

Over the past year, the average rent in Shirley, NY have increased by approximately 0%, which translates to $104 per month. This change reflects shifting market trends and evolving housing demand in the area, impacting renters' costs and affordability.

The Average rent price in Shirley, NY for June 2025 is $1250, which is $81 less than in May.